India Should Worry About its Public Debt

THEIASHUB
Get an Instant Call Back from Our Expert Mentors Now!
+91

Context: India must be worried about the economic repercussions from a debt overhang that a large fiscal stimulus will entail post-covid-19 economic recovery.

Trends of Rising Public Debt in India

  • Till 1972 – Rise in general debt for the Centre and state: to about 39% of Gross Domestic Product (GDP)In 1974 - fell sharply Explosive growth after 1996: reached 57% in 2005 and in 2018 approximately 57% of GDP. (Chart 1)

Arguments favouring the Budget move of raising public debt:

  • Pandemic induced low-interest rates: 
    • Lower interest rates mean countries are less constrained by fiscal space. 
    • Large fiscal expansions can thus improve fiscal sustainability by raising GDP more than they raise debt and interest payments.
    • E.g. despite a ballooning US federal debt/ GDP ratio from below 50% in 2000 to about 100% in 2020, federal interest payments in the US is only about 1-2% of GDP.
    • This has led to the birth of New Fiscal Consensus: the notion that in a world of low-interest rates, advanced economies can run limited primary deficits and have stable public debt.

          Key Components that Altered Public Debt in India (between 1951-2018): 

          • Inflation: Inflation is the dominant component in reducing India’s public debt. 
            • Although the inflation component has begun to diminish after the adoption of flexible inflation targeting (FIT) in India in 2014.
            • Negative implication of inflation-induced debt liquidation:
              • Negative co-movement between the inflation component and REER.
              • Increased volatility and uncertainty in inflation based liquidation due impact on Household savings and REER
          • Interest rate: Out of the 5% increase in India’s public debt between 2008 and 2018, around 12% is the due nominal interest rate.
            • Since 2006, the interest rate component, helped by enacting the Fiscal Responsibility and Budgetary Management Act, exhibits a marked decline.
            • For all outstanding central and state securities, the weighted average nominal return continues to be high and has averaged around 7% around 5% in the last five years. 
          • Real GDP growth: debt can be liquidated by high real GDP growth, (as it did between 2003-08). There is a positive co-movement of growth with the following
            • Real Effective Exchange Rate (REER)
            • Households savings
            • Debt liquidation by growth tends to bring down uncertainty, debt liquidation via inflation led to more uncertainty in the economy.

                  Economic repercussions from high debt: it alters interactions between monetary, fiscal and debt management policy

                  • Raises spectre of fiscal dominance: since 1951, the sustainability of Indian public debt has been helped by debt liquidation in an environment of fiscal dominance.
                  • Interest rate continues to remain elevated despite trending down (recent interest payments/GDP ratio has averaged about 1% of GDP).
                  • Raises debt servicing cost: public health and education allocations which are already abysmally low suffer due to rising debt-servicing costs.

                      QEP Premium 2025 (B5)
                      QEP Premium 2025 (B5)
                      Buy now
                      Fill out form for more details
                      I agree to give my consent to receive updates through SMS/Email & WhatsApp*.

                      Prelims Samadhaan + Mentorship 2025
                      Prelims Samadhaan + Mentorship 2025
                      Buy now



                      Join theIAShub’s Mains Answer Writing Program

                      Refine your answer writing skills and elevate your UPSC preparation with personalized support and expert feedback.

                      Fill out the form to get started with the program or any other enquiries !

                      I agree to give my consent to receive updates through SMS/Email & WhatsApp*.